Wikipedia

Template:Why

Template Talk

[why?]

Template documentation[view] [edit] [history] [purge]

Usage

See also: Template:Purpose

To tag a statement as being in need of clarification, add the following code:

{{Why|reason=Your explanation here|date=January 2023}}
  • This tag adds pages with tagged statements into Category:Wikipedia articles needing clarification, or a dated subcategory thereof.
  • To automatically add the current date, you can use substitution: {{subst:Why?}}.
  • The |date= parameter need not be added by the editor: if not entered, a bot will soon add it. The date parameter consists of the full English name of the current month with initial capital, a space, and the year, not full dates; e.g., "January 2013", but not "jan13". Any deviation from these two rules will result in an "invalid date parameter" error.
  • The |reason= parameter is optional but often helpful. It is displayed as a tooltip in some browsers (hover the mouse here [why?] to check behavior of your browser). For example, the following usage might be appropriate to the claim that "Humphrey Bogart has won several snooker world championships":
    {{Why|reason=This claim isn't clear.|date=January 2023}}
    • Use only plain text for the |reason= parameter. It does not support wiki markup like wikilinks, which can "mess up" the tooltip.
    • Double quotation marks used within the |reason= parameter will likewise "mess up" the tooltip; use single quotes or the HTML code " instead.
  • This template should be installed directly after punctuation, such as a full stop (period) or a comma.
  • Remove the template when you add an explanation for a statement.

TemplateData

This is the TemplateData for this template used by TemplateWizard, VisualEditor and other tools. Click here to see a monthly parameter usage report for this template based on this TemplateData.

TemplateData for Why

A cleanup tag to indicate that a statement is in need of causal clarification.

[Edit template data]

Template parameters

This template prefers inline formatting of parameters.

ParameterDescriptionTypeStatus
Reason askedreason

Explanation of why causal clarity is needed

Example
It's unclear how oil expropriation led to prosperity. Please explain.
Stringoptional
Month and yeardate

Provides the month and year of the citation request; e.g., 'January 2013', but not 'jan13'

Auto value
{{subst:CURRENTMONTHNAME}} {{subst:CURRENTYEAR}}
Stringsuggested
  • v
  • t
  • e
Inline cleanup tags
Attribution
  • {{According to whom}}
  • {{Attribution needed}}
  • {{By whom}}
  • {{From whom?}}
  • {{Like whom?}}
  • {{To whom?}}
  • {{Who}}
  • {{With whom}}
Clarity
  • {{Ambiguous}}
  • {{Clarify}}
  • {{Clarify span}}
  • {{Clarify timeframe}}
  • {{Context inline}}
  • {{Expand acronym}}
  • {{Incomprehensible inline}}
  • {{Incomprehensible inline span}}
  • {{Non sequitur}}
  • {{Sentence fragment}}
  • {{Which calendar}}
Miscellaneous
  • {{Chinese script needed inline}}
  • {{Copyright violation}}
  • {{Copyvio link}}
  • {{Data missing}}
  • {{Disambiguation needed}}
  • {{External links inline}}
  • {{Improve caption}}
  • {{Needs IPA}}
  • {{Original research inline}}
  • {{Original research span}}
  • {{Pronunciation needed}}
  • {{Siadn}}
  • {{Spam link}}
  • {{Synthesis inline}}
  • {{Synthesis inline span}}
  • {{Under discussion inline}}
  • {{Verify spelling}}
  • {{Whose translation}}
Neutrality
  • {{Buzzword inline}}
  • {{Compared to?}}
  • {{Editorializing}}
  • {{Fact or opinion}}
  • {{Opinion}}
  • {{Peacock inline}}
  • {{POV statement}}
  • {{Promotion inline}}
  • {{Unbalanced opinion}}
  • {{Weasel inline}}
  • {{Weasel word some span}}
Precision
  • {{By how much}}
  • {{Definition}}
  • {{Definition needed}}
  • {{Example needed}}
  • {{Example needed span}}
  • {{Explain}}
  • {{How}}
  • {{How often}}
  • {{Misquoted}}
  • {{Quantify}}
  • {{Specify}}
  • {{Vague}}
  • {{When}}
  • {{Where}}
  • {{Which}}
  • {{Who else}}
  • {{Why}}
  • {{Year needed}}
Excessive
  • {{Duplication span}}
  • {{Importance inline}}
  • {{Relevance inline}}
  • {{Undue weight inline}}
  • {{Globalize-inline}}
Time-sensitivity
  • {{Anachronism inline}}
  • {{Clarify timeframe}}
  • {{Current event inline}}
  • {{Is this date calibrated?}}
  • {{Update after}}
  • {{Update inline}}
  • {{Update inline span}}
Verifiability
Dubious
  • {{Contradict-inline}}
  • {{Disputed inline}}
  • {{Dubious}}
  • {{Dubious span}}
  • {{Inconsistent}}
  • {{Needs independent confirmation}}
  • {{Speculation inline}}
Bare URLs
  • {{Bare URL inline}}
  • {{Bare URL non-HTML}}
  • {{Bare URL AV media}}
  • {{Bare URL PDF}}
  • {{Bare URL image}}
  • {{Bare URL DOC}}
  • {{Bare URL plain text}}
  • {{Bare URL spreadsheet}}
Incomplete or
broken citation
  • {{Author incomplete}}
  • {{Author missing}}
  • {{Date missing}}
  • {{Dead link}}
  • {{Edition needed}}
  • {{Episode needed}}
  • {{Full citation needed}}
  • {{Incomplete short citation}}
  • {{ISBN missing}}
  • {{Moved resource}}
  • {{Page needed}}
  • {{Place missing}}
  • {{Publisher missing}}
  • {{Season needed}}
  • {{Time needed}}
  • {{Title incomplete}}
  • {{Title missing}}
  • {{Volume needed}}
  • {{Year missing}}
Missing or
problematic
reference
  • {{Additional citation needed}}
  • {{Better source needed}}
  • {{Better source needed example}}
  • {{Check quotation}}
  • {{Chronology citation needed}}
  • {{Citation needed}}
  • {{Citation needed span}}
  • {{Citation not found}}
  • {{COI source}}
  • {{Deprecated inline}}
  • {{Excessive citations inline}}
  • {{Failed verification}}
  • {{Failed verification span}}
  • {{Imagefact}}
  • {{Irrelevant citation}}
  • {{Medical citation needed}}
  • {{Medical citation needed span}}
  • {{Nonspecific}}
  • {{Not verified in body}}
  • {{Obsolete source}}
  • {{Page range too broad}}
  • {{Primary source inline}}
  • {{Promotional source}}
  • {{Quote without source}}
  • {{Request quotation}}
  • {{Request quotation span}}
  • {{Retracted}}
  • {{Scientific citation needed}}
  • {{Self-published inline}}
  • {{Tertiary source inline}}
  • {{Third-party inline}}
  • {{Unreliable fringe source}}
  • {{Unreliable medical source}}
  • {{Unreliable source?}}
  • {{Verify quote}}
  • {{Verify source}}
Wording
  • {{Buzzword inline}}
  • {{Colloquialism}}
  • {{Copy edit inline}}
  • {{Neologism inline}}
  • {{Technical inline}}
  • {{Tone inline}}
General advice
  • Citing sources
  • Reliable sources
  • Maintenance template removal
  • Citation needed
  • Find sources
  • Combining sources
  • Referencing styles
  • Inline cleanup templates
  •  WikiProject Inline Templates
The above documentation is transcluded from Template:Why/doc. (edit | history)
Editors can experiment in this template's sandbox (edit | diff) and testcases (create) pages.
Add categories to the /doc subpage. Subpages of this template.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Template:Why&oldid=871542080"